In 1939, Winston Churchill famously said of Russia: "it is a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma." In 2011, upon setting foot in Moscow for the first time, I offer up the following unsolicited addendum: "Russia is a fever dream, swaddled in history, nursing a hangover..."
Friday, April 22, 2011
Exiting the Enigma
long rides on roads framed by tenements aging with the weight of decaying paint
turquoise-topped eastern orthodox churches filled with portraits of bearded saints
random police checkpoints for troopers to peep our papers
a city of billionaires and dubious white collar bank capers
suffused into every street corner, relics of a revolution gone wrong
a reminder of a century ruled by an unaccountable throng
theoretical foundations of a nation that cratered in on itself
collapsed in exhaustion
the cost in human capital was too high
i watch cumulus clouds piling up against a blue spring sky
smokestacks ringing the river
industrial facades
a century of cultivated indifference to God
a state whose mandate was far too broad
i bring American baggage to this place
staring at the silhouettes of Slavic faces
stoic staid unsmiling men wearing inscrutable scowls
some lean & squinting & others flushed with ruddy jowls
gesturing with gloved hands & brows furrowed against the wind
foreheads wrinkling as they eye women impossibly thin
leggy nordic beauties tottering by in precarious high heels
wrapped in waist coats & fashion statements that both conceal & reveal
so surreal, this post-Soviet spectacle
everyone suddenly a market receptacle
both raw & convoluted
both evolving & deeply rooted
i sip on vodka & sample the potatoes
stare at rye fields in endless rows
eye the birch forests & read of Chaubin's cosmic chaotic constructions
everywhere an eruption of repressed urges
what was purged in the past exists now in the present
so much twisting of the dogma till it no longer means what it once meant
so much is complicated but this much is evident:
new systems await old systems' descent...
Thursday, April 21, 2011
Quotes for the Day - Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
"It is not because the truth is too difficult to see that we make mistakes... we make mistakes because the easiest and most comfortable course for us is to seek insight where it accords with our emotions - especially selfish ones."
"A state of war only serves as an excuse for domestic tyranny. "
"Any man who has once proclaimed violence as his method is inevitably forced to take the lie as his principle."
"For a country to have a great writer is like having a second government. That is why no regime has ever loved great writers, only minor ones."
"Hastiness and superficiality are the psychic diseases of the 20th century, and more than anywhere else this disease is reflected in the press."
"Man has set for himself the goal of conquering the world but in the processes loses his soul."
Long Day
Master & Margarita - The Devil in the Park
Capitalism vs. Communism
This place is triggering reflections on deeply-held beliefs I've been carrying for a long time. As someone who has spent their entire career working in marketing, perhaps I'm not in the best position to offer a critique on global capitalism, but I can't help thinking about it while beholding the legacy of communism here in Russia... I was told for so many years that these ideologies were diametrically opposed, but upon examining them up close, I see the same human frailties undermining them. Walking around in a newly liberalized Russian economy is making me question the many claims I heard decades ago about the inherent flaws of state-controlled markets... It's not that those claims were inaccurate, but I'm only now really understanding how steeped in cultural bigotry my perspective was. I grew up in Reagan's America, after all... The consequences of that I'm only now fully recognizing.
I find jingoistic patriotism truly appalling. It’s essentially thinly veiled-tribalism, and while it’s often couched in language that gives lip service to specific cultural values, there’s usually an inherent claim to superiority whenever someone talks about how great their country is. I especially find it distressing when Americans do it, because I am one, and I am acutely aware of the idiocies of American foreign policy over the course of the last 30 years. I believe that any close scrutiny of the US's involvement in Vietnam, El Salvador, NAFTA, Grenada, or Iraq reveals some absolutely heinous double-standards between my country's high-minded ideals and what it actually does outside of its borders. My country gives a lot of lip service to democracy and freedom and some very evolved idea, but too often its people ignore the actual reality of our country's actions in the world.... Mark Twain captured this sentiment perfectly in this quote from "A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court":
“My kind of loyalty was loyalty to one's country, not to its institutions or its officeholders. The country is the real thing, the substantial thing, the eternal thing; it is the thing to watch over, and care for, and be loyal to; institutions are extraneous, they are its mere clothing, and clothing can wear out, become ragged, cease to be comfortable, cease to protect the body from winter, disease, and death.”
I bring this up because I find myself thinking about America’s perspective on the cold war, two decades after the fall of the Soviet Union. There’s a tendency in the United States to believe that “America won” the Cold War, that the swift dissolution of the Soviet Union from 1989 onwards somehow meant that America was triumphant, and that our country prevailed and our system is somehow superior. Unfortunately, it’s really not that simple. Yes, in the century-long struggle between communism and capitalism, capitalism has clearly proven to be a much more viable form of economic theory, and a far better basis for running the world's economy. It's much more rooted in essential truths about human nature. But any deep examination of the last twenty years, comparing and contrasting Soviet Communism and American capitalism, has to arrive at the conclusion that both of these systems have failed humanity in many ways. The free market may have won the battle between the Soviet Union and the West, but unfettered American corporate capitalism has an unsustainable trajectory, and is continually creating externalities that threaten the collective health of our societies and our shared environment. It remains to be seen how this kind of capitalism will play out. The global financial crisis of 2008 is a perfect example of how unregulated commerce is essentially redistributing wealth upwards to a handful of greedy, unchecked power brokers who have no interests to tend to but their own pocketbooks. The post-Soviet World-Bank initiated "structural adjustment programs" had similar results, where publicly owned enterprises were dismantled, privatizing profits in a way that ultimately undermined the collective economic health of Russia, affecting countless Russian citizens....
Hmmmm... I don't know where I'm going with this.... Winston Churchill's famous quote about democracy comes to mind: "...democracy is the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried." While that comment is about political systems, I feel the same way about our economic systems. There has to be a better way. The dogmatic voices from nations like the USA and Soviet Union ruled the 20th century, as they used us all in a proxy war between the ideologies of capitalism and communism... I'm hoping for more pragmatic, reasoned voices to emerge over the course of the 21st, and hopefully, we'll stumble on a system that is more equitable for the billions of people we share this planet with...
Wednesday, April 20, 2011
Meeting the Gang @ The All-Time Bar
After getting back to the hotel, Rosalie and I cleaned up and hopped in a taxi to the Holiday Inn to setup our meeting room. We accidentally had the address for the wrong hotel, and after a rather surreal search of all the hotel's ballrooms, realized our meeting was in the Holiday Inn across town. Sigh. Things like that only happen to dumb-ass visitors or tourists in a place who have no clue about where they're at. Like us. Anyhow, grabbed another taxi, made it to the room, met up with our clients a little late, and spent the next 3 hours setting up the room. Unpacking our gear, laying out documents, testing the DVDs we were given, and just making sure the meeting tomorrow would go seamlessly. We've orchestrated dozens of these meetings for the folks from Leo Burnett, but this is only the second time I've been in a conference run by the client with competing agencies present. McDonald's employs DDB, TBWA, and Leo Burnett in Eastern Europe to promote their business, and all three agencies, from a half-dozen different countries are going to be in the room tomorrow. There's a lot more to be stressed out about this time around... Anyhow, we got it done, and then headed out to a big dinner hosted by McDonald's Russia at the All-Time Bar, a local establishment run by one Dmitri Sokolov, a famed Muscovite who apparently is one the city's better-known barkeeps. It turned out to be quite an evening.
Our very hospitable client spent the night wandering around the bar with bottles of vodka ensuring that everyone within arm's reach had a glass full of vodka. I'm all for ice breakers but I learned pretty early in the evening that if I was going to be coherent, it was probably a good idea to avoid being seen by the client. It was all in good nature, though, and the alcohol definitely eased the tension up and helped facilitate some really interesting conversations amongst our table mates.
I don't spend a lot of time with people from competing agencies. I don't know if it's something a lot of ad folks do, unless you've reached a certain level of notoriety in this industry. I suppose the big bosses are used to hobnobbing with the competition, and fighting over clients at pitches, and rubbing elbows at award shows. For me it was a novel experience. Given that creatives are such mercenaries, though, perhaps they're used to it, as a lot of talented folks bounce from agency to agency seeking out the plushest of assignments. I found it insightful and illuminating to talk to folks from TBWA and DDB in the region, as I haven't spent a lot of time with people from the Baltic states. They've had quite a life, enduring governments falling and rising in the wake of the Soviet Union's collapse. It's always a learning experience to converse with folks from places you've only ever read about, and hear about their perspective on experiences you share in common. I enjoyed my dinner and the constant stream of vodka kept the conversation lively. I particularly enjoyed meeting Richard Russell, of DDB in the UK. He's a contemporary of my boss Mark Tutssel, and had a lot of interesting stories to share and insight into the business. He also wrote Honda "Grrr", one of the best ads of the past decade, and it's always nice to meet the people behind work you admire. Especially when those people turn out be personable, approachable, and entertaining - it reaffirms your belief that maybe the business isn't as cutthroat as it often seems. Suffused with vodka, my evening unfolded beautifully, and I stumbled back to the hotel with Rosalie a few hours later with a renewed appreciation for Moscow, McDonald's, Leo Burnett, and TBWA and DDB. Perhaps I'm just where I ought to be, surrounded by good creative people and learning new things. Life is good.
Behemoth
Thoughts on Gatekeepers & Dogma
Saw a lot of interesting religious architecture today... The variety of it all and the history it's framed against got me to thinking about how power interacts with faith, and what a dangerous combination it is... I got back to the hotel and typed the following:
When priests and pastors and rabbis and mullahs claim there is only one path to God, they are betraying their own vested interests… Those who are the most adamant about a singular, exclusive path to God are those who hold stock in the institutions that seek to control humankind’s spiritual inclinations. These are the gatekeepers. They are miserable toll booth operators on the highways to higher states of being, and they exist only to tax souls and collect revenue from travelers who don’t wish to venture from the roads and maps laid out by their ancestors. But God is not some isolated destination you can only access by select roads. God is everywhere. You can stray off-road and still find divinity infused in everything you encounter, and there is no need to pay tribute to the fear merchants who hold court over the unimaginative hordes of humanity who only trust the religious institutions they’ve inherited. Taking the path less traveled is as valid as the footpaths trodden by billions. It doesn’t matter what road you’re on or what vehicle you’re riding, time makes corpses of us all and what ultimately matters is not which road you're on but the quality of your journey to the beyond…
The Saga of the Toothpaste Tube
Vasisthasana in Red Square
St.Basil's Cathedral - from the Inside
Leo Burnett / Moscow
The Statue of Peter the Great...Eyesore or Embellishment?
"Just because communism ended doesn’t mean that Russia has stopped building grotesque, propagandistic statues. The master of the form is Georgian-born artist Zurab Tsereteli, best known for the garish 315-foot maritime statue of Peter the Great looming over the Moskva River. The statue was commissioned by Tsereteli’s frequent booster, Moscow Mayor Yuri Luzhkov, and has fast become a popular tourist attraction, if not exactly for the reasons its planners hoped."
Apparently Russian authorities are considering moving this to St.Petersburg, for reasons I can't quite wrap my head around. Art this big isn't meant to be deconstructed and transported anywhere...
Cathedral of Christ the Savior
The video below is appalling, and a testament to the trials and tribulations this country endured in the last century. Joseph Stalin ordered this beautiful Church destroyed, as part of the state's campaign against religion. There are not a lot of places in the world where the destruction of sacred architecture is mandated by the state, and when it does happen, it is always a tragedy and travesty and an object lesson in intolerance. Watch the video below. This is what dogma does to beauty.
Winds of Change
I made friends with a group of beautiful girls, as teenage boys are wont to do. I think they let me into their circle because I was a non-threatening, somewhat clownish little runt who was entertaining to have around. Of course, I was also voted "Most Teddy-Bear Like" for my yearbook 2 years running, but that's a story for another day. I bring up this lovely coterie of companions because they used to invite along with them to eat dinner and sing Karaoke at a Thai restaurant called Sawasdee. I'd never been to a karaoke restaurant before, but I learned really quickly that it was a whole lot of fun, even if I never got up the guts to grab the mic. My friends would sing the kind of cheesy ballads teenage girls adore, like Richard Marx's "Right Here Waiting" or the "Theme from Ice Castles," or maybe "Lean On Me" if the spirit moved them. On a couple of occasion I remember my friend Andrea singing "Winds of Change," a rock ballad by The Scorpions that had particular meaning to those of us coming into an adult awareness in 1991... This song, by a German rock band, is one of the top 50 best selling singles of all time, and represents the huge surge of hope and optimism that accompanied the fall of the Berlin wall and the end of the Soviet Union... I remembered it as I walked past Red Square this afternoon, as "I followed the Moscva, down to Gorky Park, listening to the winds..."
...it's funny how some music marinates in your mind and takes on new meanings over time...
The Kremlin Walls
St. Basil's Cathedral
"Architectural specialists are to this day unable to agree about the governing idea behind the structure. Either the creators were paying homage to the churches of Jerusalem, or, by building eight churches around a central ninth, they were representing the medieval symbol of the eight-pointed star. The original concept of the Cathedral of the Intercession has been hidden from us beneath layers of stylistic additions and new churches added to the main building. In fact, when built, the Cathedral was all white to match the white-stone Kremlin, and the onion domes were gold rather than multi-colored and patterned as they are today.
In the 17th century a hip-roofed bell tower was added, the gallery and staircases were covered with vaulted roofing, and the helmeted domes were replaced with decorated ones. In 1860 during rebuilding, the Cathedral was painted with a more complex and integrated design, and has remained unchanged since."
This is not my picture, but it's a nice one with the facade and outer form clearly visible:
Lenin's Mausoleum
"Sometimes - history needs a push."
"Despair is typical of those who do not understand the causes of evil, see no way out, and are incapable of struggle. The modern industrial proletariat does not belong to the category of such classes."
"Under socialism all will govern in turn and will soon become accustomed to no one governing."
"Give me four years to teach the children and the seed I have sown will never be uprooted."
"When there is state there can be no freedom, but when there is freedom there will be no state."
"Can a nation be free if it oppresses other nations? It cannot."
This is a miniscule sampling of his thought. His life and writing are well worth a deep dive, if you've got the time and have a penchant for history. Just because an ideology is discredited as a basis for government doesn't mean the men who breathed life into it aren't worth examining... Contradictions make for rich characters...
The Entrance of Red Square
We enter Red Square from the north. It sits at the bottom of a hill from our hotel, and serves as a corridor of power alongside the huge walls of the Kremlin. All the buildings are framed against the river, and the whole complex serves as a strategic location that dominates the entire area. Everything is built in concentric circles around this seat of power. Here's a nice post from someone at Moscow-life.com:
"...Located on the site of the city’s old market place, over the years Red Square has acted as Moscow's equivalent to ancient Rome's Forum - a vast meeting place for the people. It has been a place for celebrating religious festivals, for public gatherings, for listening to Government announcements or Tsars’ addresses, and even watching executions (various political dissidents were publicly butchered here by Ivan the Terrible and Peter the Great). The square has also been the scene of more than one display of Russian military might – the most notable of which was in 1941 when lines of Russian tanks rolled through on their way to a front-line confrontation with the Germans. It provided a much needed boost to Russians’ morale in their greatest hour of danger. More recently the square hosted the Russian Live 8 concert, supporting the fight against world poverty..."
Map of Moscow
View Larger Map
I wake to a half day free. We can't start working till 3 pm, so we have the morning to wander around Moscow, and get in some fast-paced tourism. We're not far from Red Square, it's within walking distance, so we'll venture down there and see where that leads. The size of this city is daunting. I took a quick glance at a subway system map outside a metro stop, and found it completely overwhelming. I couldn't even find a helpful "you are here" indicator. Have a look at these maps... The city is named after the Moskva River which runs through it, and the entire area appears to be ringed by highways... It's a bit tough to wrap your around new geographies when the scripts render you illiterate and you can't really tell what scale any of the maps are in. Perhaps a few hours of wandering on foot will clarify things...
Tuesday, April 19, 2011
Tolstoy Quotes of the Day
Leo Tolstoy
"If there existed no external means for dimming their consciences, one-half of the men would at once shoot themselves, because to live contrary to one's reason is a most intolerable state, and all men of our time are in such a state."
"The greater the state, the more wrong and cruel its patriotism, and the greater is the sum of suffering upon which its power is founded."
Leo Tolstoy
Hollywood Myths
Aleksandr Pushkin
Here's a piece from Russia's great Romantic poet from the 19th century... 1821 I have outlasted all desire, My dreams and I have grown apart; My grief alone is left entire, The gleanings of an empty heart. The storms of ruthless dispensation Have struck my flowery garland numb- I live in lonely desolation And wonder when my end will come. Thus on a naked tree-limb, blasted By tardy winter's whistling chill, A single leaf which has outlasted Its season will be trembling still. | ||
|
Dining @ the Golden Apple
Essential Russian Phrases
Hmmm...these "essential russian phrases" would help if I could read them... The BBC has a nice audio guide though...
Yes: Da
No: Nyiet
Please: Puzhalsta
Thank You: Das Vidanya
from "The Master & Margarita"
"But would you kindly ponder this question: What would your good do if evil didn't exist, and what would the earth look like if all the shadows disappeared? After all, shadows are cast by things and people. Here is the shadow of my sword. But shadows also come from trees and living beings. Do you want to strip the earth of all trees and living things just because of your fantasy of enjoying naked light? You're stupid."
— Mikhail Bulgakov
from The Master and Margarita
Last year when I was first told I might have opportunity to travel to Russia I made a quick trip to a used bookstore and picked up as many classic Russian novels as I thought I might be able to read. They're heavy, voluminous works written by some truly great minds, with ponderous themes and some really vivid characters. I particularly enjoyed Mikhail Bulgakov's "The Master & Margarita", and look forward to reading it a few more times over the course of my life. The premise? The devil descends upon Moscow as a professional magician from the west offering a theatrical performance of astonishing complexity... There is so much delightful subversion and social commentary in the novel, and you'll see a more posts from this book over the course of this blog because it's simply delightful. Tomorrow i'll point you towards Bulgakov's description of the devil's big black cat named Behemoth...
Onion Domes
Interesting onion domes dot the city's skyline. Not a lot of them, as this is hardly a city with religion as it's primary focus, but enough of them to leave a deep impression. Check out the video above about Onion domes as a feature of Russian Church architecture.
Government Housing
Futuristic Moscow - The Gift by Philips
Birch Trees & Bureaucrats
Walking out of the terminal is a wake up call. A cold wind hits my face, snow flurries drift into my hair, and I'm reminded that spring is a relative term that holds different meanings to different people. We gather our things and depart with the hotel's driver.
Everywhere birch trees. You could see them flying in, too, for as far as the eye can see. They fill the landscape amidst the fields, surreal forests of tall trees with white bark and long, spindly trunks reaching skyward. They're gorgeous & quite distinct... Below is a pic, and below that the Russian Red Army Choir singing about the birch tree...